Tomorrow I will travel more than 3,000 kilometers, as the crow flies, to witness a little piece of combat sports history at the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) debut Toronto event (Happy 32nd birthday to me!). Roughly 55,000 mixed martial arts fans will pack the Roger’s Center, and maybe a million more will tune in to pay-per-view to watch UFC Welterweight champion Georges St-Pierre (affectionately known as GSP) defend his belt – most likely successfully – for the last time.
A two-time Rogers Sportsnet Canadian Athlete of the Year, GSP is not retiring; rather, he’s so good that he’s cleaned out the welterweight (156-170 pound) division and needs to move up a weight class to find another fighter who can give him a run for his money. His background is in karate, his wrestling is world class, his jiu-jitsu is strategically sound and he follows carefully orchestrated game plans for each match-up, capitalizing on the specific weaknesses of his opponent. GSP is known for being a gentleman’s fighter and a highly intelligent and principled person.
The middleweight (171-185 pound) division, to which GSP will be rising, is currently dominated by a lightening-fast, creative and playful fighter from Brazil named Anderson Silva. This guy pulls off moves that look like they’re from The Matrix and in most of his fights he is visibly bored, filling the time with showy capoeira dancing and general mockery of his opponents. His striking is spookily accurate and he regularly embarrasses even elite fighters. In the GSP-Silva fight, the odds are on Silva.
There is no set formula for fight match-ups in UFC. They tend to arise both from the art of matchmaker Joe Silva (no relation to Anderson) and from political will among the fan base. The projected superfight is being held partly in the service of an abstract question dear to the hearts of combat sports fans: Who is the best Pound-for-Pound fighter in the world? That is, if all questions of natural physique are held constant, who wins the contest of skill?